Scenarios for Review
The following is a summary of the some of the key concepts for each chapter, followed by possible situations with which local officials, planning commissioners and others may be asked to deal.
What would you do? Imagine yourself in a real-life circumstance in which you are a part of the land use process. Once you have thought about what you would do, you can click on the "Response" section to see a possible response. Although the response should be accurate and help to reinforce chapter content it may not be the only appropriate response that could be provided.
Please refer to the full chapter for reference information and should you have any questions. Click here for a list of field representatives and Department of Land Conservation and Development staff.
Show all chapter responses | Hide all chapter responses
Chapter 1 - Key Concepts
- The Oregon Planning Program is a partnership between state and local government.
- The Land Conservation and Development Commission (LCDC) sets broad policies in the form of statewide planning goals and administrative rules.
- The Department of Land Conservation and Development (DLCD) is the state agency that provides administrative oversight and technical assistance related to the statewide planning program.
- Cities and counties adopt comprehensive plans and implementing land use regulations consistent with statewide planning goals.
- Comprehensive plans provide a framework that guides future development, streets, water and sewer service, parks and other services.
- Citizen involvement is required for all phases of the planning process. Such involvement has the ability to significantly influence the process, within the framework of the jurisdictions adopted comprehensive plan polices and implementing code requirements.
- Zoning, subdivision ordinances, transportation system plans, local budget decisions and capital improvement programs are sample tools communities use to implement their comprehensive plans.
Imagine that you are a Planning Commissioner in your community. You are asked by a high school civics class why planning and zoning is important. What would you say?
The local Chamber of Commerce has asked you for background on Oregon’s planning program. How would you describe planning in a way that shows its relevance to your community?
Chapter 2 - Key Concepts
- Cities and counties must jointly agree on an urban growth boundary that separates urban development from rural and natural resource areas.
- A city, through its comprehensive plan, must include an adequate supply of land for housing, economic growth and livability, within its urban growth boundary.
- Zoning standards and conditions for housing must be “clear and objective” and consistent with plan policies so that they don’t deny or delay development that is consistent with the plan.
- County plans and regulations should protect the agricultural and forest land base.
You are a planning commissioner for a city that is updating its comprehensive plan and considering changes to the urban growth boundary. What key information would you need to make an informed decision?
You are an elected county official. A local farmer asks you about the requirements to subdivide his property to sell parcels for residential development. Based on your understanding of agricultural land protection requirements, what do you say?
Your neighbor tells you she is considering buying a house near a small stream. She is also considering making small additions to the structure. What advice would you give her about land use provisions that may apply?
Chapter 3 - Key Concepts
- Planning is a process that includes assessing current conditions, collecting data, setting goals and adopting implementing rules and regulations to reach those goals.
- A comprehensive plan includes both a map (or maps) and policies to guide future growth and development.
- Implementing measures translate the comprehensive plan map and policies into regulations that apply to specific properties.
- There are several approaches to zoning, but all regulate allowed land uses and activities in a manner consistent with the comprehensive plan.
Your community is considering the need to expand the urban growth boundary to add large lot industrial land for business use. On what type of factual information must you base your decision?
To accommodate growth, your community is considering a new approach to housing. The city currently divides residential categories into low-density single family, medium-density single family and multi-family areas. What adjustments can you consider to allow for more flexible development choices?
At a planning commission hearing, you are asked to consider a request to adjust or remove the front yard setback requirement (a variance). What are the important factors you will need to consider?
Chapter 4 - Key Concepts
- The three types of local government land use decisions are legislative, quasi-judicial and administrative (ministerial).
- Quasi-judicial land use decisions require “due process” protections of notice, hearing and decisions supported by findings of fact.
- A public official cannot participate in a land use decision if they have an actual conflict of interest.
- Local officials can discuss land use issues with staff. These discussions are not ex-parte contacts and do not require disclosure.
You are describing the land use decision process to a community group. How would you explain the process in language non-planers can understand?
As a planning commissioner, you visit the site of a proposed development prior to a public hearing. At the hearing, what should you disclose about this visit?
As a member of the planning commission, you have completed the hearing and deliberations for a quasi-judicial land use decision. The commission is required to support its decision with "findings of fact," but you are not sure they are adequate. What should you do?
Before a Planning Commission hearing, you are uncertain about your bias or conflict of interest. What should you do?
Chapter 5 - Key Concepts
- Oregon operates a federally approved program known as the Oregon Coastal Management Program or OCMP. This approval allows the state to apply for federal Coastal Zone Management Act or CZMA funding to support coastal planning efforts.
- The OCMP applies within the coastal zone. This generally encompasses land from the crest of the coast range to the limit of the state’s territorial sea (three nautical miles).
- The OCMP includes the statewide planning goals, local comprehensive plans and land use regulations and some state agency regulatory authorities such as the DEQ water quality requirements and DSL removal and fill law.
- Federal approval gives the state authority to review certain federal actions, including licenses and permits, to ensure they are fully consistent with OCMP requirements. In addition, direct actions must be consistent with the OCMP to the maximum extent practicable.
The US Army Corps of Engineers has plans to construct a modified channel in a coastal estuary in your community. What requirements might apply? Does the federal government preempt local and state law in this instance?
A developer wants to place wave energy devices in the ocean a short distance offshore. Which state agency has primary authority to review this development?
Chapter 6 - Key Concepts
- Estuaries are areas where the ocean and rivers mix, creating a dynamic, diverse and biologically rich environment.
- Oregon estuaries are divided into three categories: natural, conservation and development.
- Uses and activities within estuaries are regulated according to their estuary classification.
- Each estuary is organized into “management units” that govern development.
- Projects that alter the estuary are first subject to impact assessments. The assessment may require "dredge, fill and other alterations" tests to ensure estuary health.
- Projects that adversely impact the estuarine ecosystem may require mitigation.
A citizen has told you he heard that an action proposed in an estuary in your community requires a "resource capability" test and asks you what that means. How would you describe this in non-planner terms?
A potential applicant asks you to tell her where a "natural" management unit in an estuary is appropriate.
You hear about a proposal to protect a use in your community that existed before October 7, 1977. What are some issues that must be considered?
Chapter 7 - Key Concepts
- Coastal shorelands are subject to significant development pressures due to their proximity to the ocean shore and coastal water bodies.
- The purpose of the coastal shorelands goal is to conserve and protect shoreland areas from activities that adversely impact unique or irreplaceable habitats.
- Development in shoreland areas must include measures that protect life and property from landslides, erosion and flood hazards.
- Communities must protect water-dependent shoreland areas from conflicting uses.
- Local governments and state agencies are required to protect existing public access to shoreland areas.
A developer seeks to build a motel adjacent to a coastal lake in your community. The proposed site is zoned to allow this use but is also within the communities "coastal shorelands" overlay zone. What are some of the applicable local plan and zoning code considerations?
A proposed development includes a request to vacate a street that has been platted but not improved. Currently, it is a small trail to the ocean shore. What should the local government require as part of its approval process?
Chapter 8 - Key Concepts
- Local plans must include an inventory of beach and dune forms, including active dunes, recently stabilized dunes, older stabilized dunes and interdune areas.
- The objectives of Goal 18 are to conserve, protect, where appropriate, develop and restore the resources and benefits of coastal beach and dune areas; and also to reduce hazards to life and property.
- Development is generally allowed on older stabilized dunes, but limited or prohibited on beaches, active foredunes and other foredunes subject to hazards.
- Beachfront protective structures are allowed only in areas where development existed on January 1, 1977.
- An approved comprehensive grading plan, that maintains adequate protection from coastal erosion and flooding, is required before dune grading can occur. Dune grading plans can only be authorized in an urban growth boundary or other areas designated and committed to development.
A developer in your community is interested in building on the backside of a foredune adjacent to the beach. What are the likely issues the planning commission must consider?
A property owner is in eminent peril of losing her home, built in 1974, due to a series of significant coastal erosion storm events. Is the home eligible to be protected by a beachfront protective structure?
Chapter 9 - Key Concepts
- The purpose of Goal 19 is to conserve marine resources and ecological functions.
- Goal 19 requires protection of renewable marine resources from adverse effects of development of nonrenewable resources. Only state and federal agencies have regulatory authority over the ocean.
- The state is responsible for regulating matters pertaining to the Territorial Sea but must consult with affected local governments in accordance with the requirements of the Territorial Sea Plan.
- The state’s primary policy and planning requirements are outlined in Goal 19 and the Territorial Sea Plan. Both have been adopted by the Land Conservation and Development Commission (DLCD.)
A company proposes to lay an undersea telecommunication cable. Who has authority over this project?